GGN: Plebs Become Bioelectric Drones, Experts 'Predict' Eugenic Society, Trends That Kill
BMJ OpEd Says Komen Ads False
Selective statistics used to promote mammograms, breast cancer awareness.
By Charles Bankhead, MedPage Today
Don't Miss This
Sign Up for OurCancer Care and PreventionNewsletter
Thanks for signing up!You might also like these other newsletters:
THURSDAY, Aug. 2, 2012 (MedPage Today) —The world's largest breast cancer charity used misleading statistics and deceptive statements about mammography to promote breast cancer awareness and screening, authors of an opinion piece asserted.
In promotional material for the 2011 Breast Cancer Awareness Month, Susan G. Komen for the Cure suggested large differences in breast cancer survival among women who undergo screening mammography and those who do not. Specifically, the advertisement stated a 5-year survival of 98 percent when breast cancer is caught early and 23 percent when it is not.
In doing so, the organization ignored "a growing and increasingly accepted body of evidence [showing] that although screening may reduce a woman's chance of dying from breast cancer by a small amount, it also causes major harms."
"This benefit of mammography looks so big that it is hard to imagine why any one would forgo screening. She'd have to be crazy," Steven Woloshin, MD, and Lisa M. Schwartz, MD, of the Department of Veterans Affairs Medical Center in White River Junction, Vt. and the Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy and Clinical Practice in Lebanon, N.H., wrote in an article published online inBMJ.
"But it's the advertisement that is crazy," they added.
In response to theBMJarticle, Susan G. Komen for the Cure issued a statement from Chandini Portteus, vice president of research, evaluation, and scientific programs.
"Everyone agrees that mammography isn't perfect, but it's the best widely available detection tool that we have today," said Portteus. "We've said for years that science has to do better, which is why Komen is putting millions of dollars into research to detect breast cancer before symptoms start, through biomarkers, for example."
But Woloshin and Schwartz argued that the timing of breast cancer diagnosis has minimal impact on long-term survival, citing evidence that mammography reduces a 50-year-old woman's 10-year risk of dying of breast cancer from 0.53 percent to 0.46 percent.
"Five-year survival is all about what happens from the time of diagnosis," Woloshin and Schwartz wrote. "It is the proportion of women who are alive 5 years after diagnosis. Because screening finds cancers earlier, comparing survival between screened and unscreened women is hopelessly biased."
The authors also faulted Komen's deception for emphasizing the benefits of mammography but making no mention of the possible risks. Woloshin and Schwartz cited evidence indicating that 20 percent to 50 percent of women screened annually for a decade will have at least one "false alarm" that leads to a biopsy.
For every life saved by mammography, the imaging leads to overdiagnosis of two to 10 women, many of whom receive unnecessary interventions and treatment, they added.
With regard to the need for balanced information about mammography, Komen's Portteus said, "We have long advocated for women to be informed about the benefits and risks of early detection and treatment. We encourage women to work with their healthcare providers to find out what's right for them.
"At the same time, Komen is funding millions of dollars in community health programs that educate, screen, and provide financial and social support for low-income and uninsured women through treatment," she added.
"Women need much more than marketing slogans about screening," Woloshin and Schwartz concluded. "They need — and deserve — the facts. The Komen advertisement campaign failed to provide the facts.
"Worse, it undermined decision making by misusing statistics to generate false hope about the benefit of mammography screening.
Video: What doctors don't know about the drugs they prescribe | Ben Goldacre
Strangers Ask Each Other36 Questions toFall inLove and Come toAmbiguous Conclusions
Jordin Sparks Undiet Diet
How to Overcome Wikiphobia
What Is Brucellosis
The Best Short Haircuts for Every Texture
22 Commonly Mispronounced Foods and How to Say Them
My Coming Home Coq Au Vin
How to Calculate Texas Unemployment Benefits
8 Powerful Reasons to Love Your Enemies
How to Be a Great Red Dwarf Fan
Taylor Swift Just Deleted All of Her Instagram Photos
How to Make Macaroni Pasta